Two stories from one head butler, and the simple step that would have saved both of them.
Three days
I met a head butler recently who had spent several years with one household before another employer approached him. He went through several interviews, accepted the offer and resigned. Three days after he started, he was let go.
The reason was language. Not between him and the principal or the family, but between him and the rest of the staff he was there to lead. Somewhere along the line, the recruiter, the client or the house manager assumed there would be no barrier. Nobody checked. He described it to me as the worst decision he had ever made, and it left him with no faith in the process.
Thirty minutes
On another application, he went through eight interviews. The chief of staff then told him they didn't need to see his CV again; the feedback was so good they would hire him on the spot. The final step was a courtesy meeting with the principal.
After around half an hour, he was told their personalities had clashed, and the offer went no further. Eight interviews had said yes. Thirty minutes said no.
What both stories have in common
In both cases, a decision that affected someone's whole livelihood was made on very little real information. In the first, nobody tested how he would work with the team day to day. In the second, a single short meeting outweighed weeks of process.
A trial answers both problems.
Why a trial works
A trial won't be possible for every role or every household. But where it is possible, it can add real value to the process for everyone involved.
A paid trial of two to four weeks is a risk-free way for every party to make sure the environment and the work are right. It doesn't mean closing the role to other candidates. It doesn't mean making any commitment at all. The whole purpose is that it is safe, and it gives everyone what they need to make an informed decision.
A trial should always be paid. The standard rate is simple: a day rate worked out pro rata from the annual salary.
- The family sees how the candidate works in their home, with their staff and their routines.
- The team finds out whether they can work with their new manager, in practice and not on paper.
- The candidate lives the life for a few weeks before giving up a secure role elsewhere.
After a trial, a candidate is much more likely to stick, because both sides already know what they are signing up for.
When a household doesn't offer a trial, it is usually for understandable reasons. The role may need filling urgently, or a few weeks of trial may feel like a disruption to the running of the house. Sometimes it simply hasn't been considered. In most cases, a few weeks spent getting it right costs far less than starting the search again.
How I approach it
When I take on a search, I want to understand the whole household, not just the person at the top of it: who the candidate will lead, the language the team works in, and how the house actually runs. And wherever the role allows it, I recommend a trial before anyone commits. It protects the client and the candidate alike.
If you are planning a hire for your household or family office, I would be happy to talk through how I would approach it. You deal with me personally at every step.
Based on real conversations with a candidate. Names and identifying details have been withheld. MOR did not handle either role.
